Skip to main content

Insights into Strong Ales, Barleywines Old Ales and the Double IPA

The other day I was drinking Stone's Double Bastard Ale, an American strong ale, and I realized I didn't have the greatest understanding of the differences between strong ales, barleywines, old ales and, to a lesser extent, double IPAs. In my mind, they were always kind of grouped into the group of beers that have lots of hops, lots of malt and lots of alcohol! I decided to do some research into the real differences between these beers.

To the best of my knowledge, there are two main organizations which provide beer style guidelines. The Brewer's Association (BA) provides style guidelines "as a reference for brewers and beer competition organizers."  The Beer Judge Certification Program (BJCP) uses a similar set of guidelines, but there are some differences from the BA's guidelines.  For my purposes they are similar enough, so I am going to use the BA style guidelines for my comparison.

The first think I noticed while looking at the BA style guidelines (which you can download from their website from the link above) was that there wasn't an entry for American Strong Ale.  The closest I could find was English Strong Ale.  The description of English Strong Ale is close, but doesn't quite accurately describe Stone's Double Bastard or Arrogant Bastard Ales, due to the aggressiveness of the hops used in the beers.  American Strong Ales must be considered "Out Of Category", which doesn't do me much help.  Basically, all that it tells us is that an American Strong Ale is an American style, high alcohol beer which doesn't fit into the barleywine, old ale, double IPA categories.

According to the BA, an American Barleywine is amber to deep copper in color, a full bodied 8.4-12% ABV, and can be anywhere from 60-100 International Bitterness Units (IBUs).  The high hop bitterness is balanced by fruity esters.  Some examples of American Barleywines are Sierra Nevada Bigfoot and Avery Hog Heaven Barleywine. 
Picture from www.sierranevada.com
Picture from www.averybrewing.com




The BA style guidelines lists the Imperial/Double IPA as golden to medium copper in color, medium-high to full bodied, clocking in somewhere between 7.5-10.5% ABV, and containing 65-100 IBUs.  Double IPAs are a beer designed to show off the flavors and aromas can provide.  They typically tend to have a heavy malt backbone to attempt to balance out the hops.  Prime examples are Victory Hop Wallop and Dogfish Head 90-Minute IPA.
From www.victorybeer.com
From www.dogfish.com

The BA describes Old Ales as dark amber to brown beers that are medium to full bodied, ranging between 6-9%.  They typically start between 30-65 IBUs.  There shouldn't be aroma from the hops, and minimal to medium in the flavor.  Instead, Old Ales smell and taste of fruity esters,  and when aged properly, can exhibit a rich and wine-like oxidation character.  Typical examples are Founders Curmudgeon and Great Divide Hibernation Ale.
from www.foundersbrewing.com
from www.greatdivide.com

Thanks for reading!  If you have anything to add or questions, feel free to use the comments below!
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dogfish Head Positive Contact

Frankenstorm is on it's way.  Bread: Check.  Candles: Check.  Ice: Check.  Beer: Check!  The big storm is supposed to strike land here in NJ late Sunday night into early Monday morning, and last until late Tuesday.  Kerry and I live in the western part of NJ, so we should be safe from most of it, except for local river flooding.  Tonight I'll be reviewing Positive Contact from Dogfish Head.  This is their collaboration with Dan the Automator (who I honestly had never heard of before this collaboration). I poured Positive Contact into my Yards Brewing tulip glass.  It poured a pale orange, golden color with a two and a half finger width head.  Apples, bananas and peppers hit my nose right away.  The smell is incredible and strong.  The Positive Contact is full of flavor, and reminds me of a smooth drinking Belgian tripel.  It tastes immediately of fruity esters, mainly banana.  The finish is peppery.  I'm not getting any apple flavor.  This beer is light bodied, with
Post a Comment
Read more

BJCP: Strong Scotch Ale (9E)

This is the first article in a new series of posts, where I will periodically choose a section from the Beer Judge Certification Program (BJCP) style guidelines , write about the style, and then drink and publish my tasting notes from some of the commercial examples given by the BJCP.  Now, I'm not sure if I will ever actually take the exam to become a beer judge, but I think this will be a fun exercise to learn more about beer! Fair warning, I will not be doing the sections of the BJCP style guidelines in any sort of order.  Whichever kinds of beer I am craving is what I will be writing about! Strong Scotch Ales (also known as Wee Heavy) comprise sub-category 9E in the BJCP style guidelines.  They range between 6.5% and 10.0% ABV, and have a light copper to dark brown appearance.  Obviously, strong scotch ales are all about showcasing the malt.  While studying this style, I found it quite interesting that the brewers ferment out the wort at cooler temperatures than other
15 comments
Read more

The Six-Pack Project: New Jersey

Welcome to the Six-Pack Project!  The idea of the project is to create a six-pack of beer that would best represent the current beer scene in your respective state.  For me, that is obviously New Jersey.  The Six-Pack Project was created by Bryan over at the This Is Why I'm Drunk blog.  Check out his introduction to the project here ! 10 years ago, beer probably wasn't the first thing that came to your mind when you were thinking about New Jersey.  However, times are changing, and it's an exciting time to be a beer drinker in the Garden State.  Every year, more and more bars are starting to serve a greater variety in beer.  Even more importantly, new breweries haven been opening in NJ each year, and lots more are in planning Today, there is a wide variety of beer brewed here in New Jersey.  Choosing six beers to best represent the state was no easy feat, but I was up for it!  Hopefully, the following will clue you in a little bit more to some o
13 comments
Read more